The Power of Reinforcement in Dog Training: Food or Toys?

In the world of dog training, one of the most debated topics is the choice of reinforcement method. Should trainers rely on food treats, or are toys a better option? The discussion becomes even more nuanced when we consider the context of training detection dogs, where the stakes are high, and precision is paramount. To shed light on this ongoing debate, let’s explore the insights shared by experienced trainers from diverse backgrounds. When it comes to training our detection dogs, one of the fundamental decisions we face is whether to use food or play as reinforcement. Each method offers its own set of advantages and challenges, and understanding the nuances of both is crucial for successful training outcomes. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the difficulties of food and play reinforcement strategies, discuss important considerations such as the high rate of reinforcement, overshadowing odors, and contamination of target odors.

Food Reinforcement;

Food reinforcement is a widely used method in dog training, owing to its effectiveness and ease of implementation. The primary advantage of using food as reinforcement is its precision – dogs can quickly and clearly associate the desired behavior with the reward. Additionally, food rewards can be easily delivered in small, controlled portions, making them ideal for shaping behaviors and maintaining focus during training sessions. One of the key benefits of food reinforcement is its versatility. Trainers can easily adjust the value of the food reward based on the dog’s motivation level and the difficulty of the task at hand. From high-value treats like meat or cheese to lower-value options like kibble, the range of food rewards available allows for tailored reinforcement strategies that suit individual dogs and training goals. For me personally the biggest advantage is that it is fast! I mean I can do a lot of repetitions in a short amount of time. The dog swallows the piece of food and is ready for the next trial. When I use a play reinforcer I can do less repetitions because after giving the toy I need to take some time to play with the dog. However, there are also potential drawbacks to relying solely on food reinforcement. Some dogs may become overly reliant on food rewards, leading to a lack of motivation or engagement in training sessions without them. Additionally, there is a risk of the dog developing undesirable behaviors such as begging or food aggression if not managed carefully. Moreover, in environments with high levels of distractions or arousal, food rewards may lose their effectiveness as the dog’s focus shifts away from the task at hand.

Play Reinforcement;

Play reinforcement offers an alternative approach to training that capitalizes on the dog’s natural instincts and preferences. Playing games like tug-of-war or fetch can be highly motivating for many dogs, providing both physical and mental stimulation while reinforcing desired behaviors. The dynamic nature of play makes it particularly effective for building strong bonds between dogs and their handlers and enhancing overall engagement in training. One of the primary advantages of play reinforcement is its ability to maintain high levels of motivation and excitement throughout training sessions. Unlike food rewards, which may lose their appeal over time, play can keep dogs eagerly anticipating each interaction with their handler. Additionally, play offers opportunities for natural reinforcement of desired behaviors, such as sitting before initiating a game of fetch or waiting patiently for a release cue. However, play reinforcement also has its limitations. Not all dogs are equally motivated by play, and some may prefer food rewards or other forms of reinforcement. Additionally, certain types of play, such as roughhousing or chasing games, may inadvertently reinforce undesirable behaviors like jumping or mouthing. Furthermore, play reinforcement may be less precise than food rewards, making it challenging to mark specific behaviors for reinforcement accurately.

High Rate of Reinforcement;

In both detection dog training and general obedience training, maintaining a high rate of reinforcement is crucial for shaping and reinforcing desired behaviors effectively. A high rate of reinforcement involves delivering rewards frequently and consistently, especially during the initial stages of training when building new behaviors or refining existing ones. By providing frequent reinforcement, trainers can create strong associations between the desired behavior and the reward, speeding up the learning process and increasing the dog’s motivation and engagement. Additionally, a high rate of reinforcement helps to prevent frustration or boredom in the dog, keeping them actively participating in training sessions.However, maintaining a high rate of reinforcement can be challenging, particularly when working in complex or distracting environments. Trainers must be prepared to deliver rewards quickly and efficiently, ensuring that the dog remains focused and motivated throughout the training session. Additionally, trainers should gradually decrease the rate of reinforcement as the dog becomes more proficient in the desired behavior, transitioning to intermittent reinforcement schedules to maintain long-term retention.

Understanding How Treats and Games Affect Dog Learning;

When we train our dogs, it’s like guiding them through a fun adventure. But did you know that the way we reward them with treats or games can make a big difference in how well they learn? Let’s take a closer look at how these rewards affect dogs and their excitement levels. Imagine you’re sitting in a quiet room, ready to learn something new. That’s how dogs feel when they get a treat as a reward. Treats help keep them calm and focused, making it easier for them to pay attention and learn new tricks. For dogs who are naturally calm or older dogs who prefer a slower pace, treats are like little boosts of motivation. They encourage dogs to stay focused and take part in training without getting too worked up or distracted. When dogs are in this calm state, they’re ready to soak up new information like a sponge. Every treat they get reinforces the good behavior they’ve shown, helping them learn and improve with each reward.

Games trigger more excitement;

Now, picture a bustling playground full of excitement and energy. That’s what it’s like when dogs play games as a reward. Games amp up their excitement levels and make learning feel like an exhilarating adventure. For dogs who love to play and have lots of energy, games are like a spark that ignites their enthusiasm. They get pumped up and eager to join in the fun, making training sessions lively and enjoyable. But here’s the tricky part: when dogs are super excited, it can be harder for them to focus and learn. With all the excitement swirling around, they might struggle to pay attention or follow instructions properly.

Finding the Right Balance;

So, how do we make sure dogs get the most out of their training sessions? It’s all about finding the right balance between treats and games. For dogs who prefer a calm and focused approach, treats are the way to go. Treats help them stay on track and learn at their own pace without getting too overwhelmed. On the other hand, for dogs who thrive on excitement and energy, games are the perfect reward. Games keep them engaged and motivated, but we need to be careful not to let the excitement get out of control. By understanding how treats and games affect dogs differently, we can tailor our training methods to suit each dog’s personality and needs. Whether it’s a quiet treat for a calm learner or an exciting game for an energetic pup, the key is to keep training fun and rewarding for our dogs.

Overshadowing Odors and Contamination;

In detection dog training, one of the primary challenges is mitigating the risk of overshadowing odors or contamination, which can interfere with the dog’s ability to accurately detect target odors. Overshadowing occurs when a strong or distracting odor masks the target odor, leading the dog to focus on the wrong scent source. Contamination, on the other hand, involves the inadvertent introduction of foreign odors into the training environment, potentially confusing the dog and compromising the accuracy of their responses. To minimize the risk of overshadowing odors and contamination, trainers must carefully select training environments and control for external factors that may interfere with the dog’s olfactory capabilities. Additionally, trainers should use systematic desensitization techniques to gradually introduce distracting odors or environmental stimuli, allowing the dog to acclimate and maintain focus on the target odor.

Understanding your dog’s hierarchy of food and toy rewards;

This is crucial for effective training. Knowing which rewards hold the highest value for your dog allows you to tailor your training sessions to maximize motivation and engagement. Here’s a simple game to help trainers determine their dog’s top food and toy rewards:
  1. Gather a Variety of Treats and Toys: Start by collecting an assortment of treats and toys of different types, textures, and flavors. Choose a selection that includes both high-value and low-value options, ranging from your dog’s absolute favorites to items they’re less enthusiastic about.
  2. Set Up the Game: Find a quiet, distraction-free area where you can focus on interacting with your dog. Place the treats and toys in separate piles within easy reach.
  3. Begin the Trial: Present your dog with one treat from the pile and observe their reaction. Take note of their level of excitement, eagerness to engage, and how quickly they consume the treat. Repeat this process with several different treats, offering one at a time and observing their response to each.
  4. Repeat with Toys: After assessing the food rewards, move on to the toy rewards. Offer your dog one toy at a time, allowing them to interact with it for a brief period. Pay attention to their level of interest, enthusiasm for play, and how long they engage with each toy before losing interest.
  5. Evaluate Responses: Based on your observations, rank the treats and toys in order of your dog’s preference. Identify which rewards elicit the strongest positive reactions and hold their attention the longest. These will be your dog’s high-value rewards, while those that receive a lukewarm response are considered low-value.
  6. Incorporate Into Training: Armed with this knowledge, structure your training sessions to prioritize the use of high-value rewards for reinforcing desired behaviors. Reserve low-value rewards for less demanding tasks or as occasional reinforcements.
Why It’s Important? Knowing your dog’s hierarchy of food and toy rewards is essential for several reasons:
  • Maximizing Motivation: By using high-value rewards during training, you can increase your dog’s motivation and enthusiasm, making them more eager to participate and learn.
  • Enhancing Engagement: Tailoring your training sessions to include your dog’s favorite rewards keeps them actively engaged and focused on the task at hand, reducing distractions and improving learning outcomes.
  • Building a Stronger Bond: Using rewards that your dog loves strengthens the bond between you and reinforces positive associations with training, creating a more enjoyable experience for both of you.
  • Efficient Training: Understanding which rewards hold the highest value allows you to make the most of your training time by using the most effective reinforcements, leading to faster progress and better results.
By taking the time to identify your dog’s preferred food and toy rewards, you can create training sessions that are both effective and enjoyable, setting your canine companion up for success in mastering new skills and behaviors.


In the realm of dog training, the choice between food and play reinforcement strategies depends on a variety of factors, including the dog’s individual preferences, the specific training goals, and the environmental context. Both food and play reinforcement offer unique advantages and challenges, and a balanced approach that incorporates elements of both may yield the best results. Implementing strategies to maintain a high rate of reinforcement are essential for successful training outcomes, particularly in the context of detection dog training. By carefully selecting reinforcement methods, managing potential distractions or contamination, and prioritizing the dog’s motivation and engagement, trainers can optimize their training efforts and foster strong, reliable working relationships with their canine partners. Enjoy training!

ACT! Is operating worldwide. You can find more information on my website about the ACT! innovative training products and workshops about detection, odor recognition testing, tracking, scent wheel training, laser training, and radio-directional dogs. Visit my online for the best detection products. If you are interested in the ACT workshops, don’t hesitate to contact me so I can provide you with the specific workshop you need for your organization! 

Any questions or comments?

If you have any questions or comments about this article, feel free to send me an e-mail. 

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top